In Search of Medical Science
Lots of rival camps. No
unity.
Boerhaave: bedside teaching,
Leiden, chem
Hales: iatromechanics, expts.
Stahl: animism
Hoffman: mechanism
de Sauvages: midground
John Hunter: vitalist
La Mettrie: extreme materialist
more anatomy, Sommerring; Wolff,
Naturphilosophie
regeneration - Trembley, Spallanzani
von Haller and irritability, vitalism.
Whytt
epigenesis vs. prefomation
Three Warring Schools
dualistic
mechanism
|
animisim
|
atheistic
reductionism
|
Blumenbach
John Hunter
|
Galvani
Volta
|
Erasmus Darwin
JB Lamarck
|
-
pneumatic chemistry and respiration
-
Cavendish, Black, Priestley, Lavoisier
-
Beddoes Institute
Medicine in Practice
-
men of letters, philanthropists, improvers
-
E. Darwin, JC Lettsom
-
W. Heberden
-
1761 Auenbruegger and percussion Inventum
novum
-
History still more important than 5 senses.
The Study of Disease
Fothergill, Lind, Dobson;
Cheyne; Tissot
Piecemeall advances, with fundamentals
remaining contentious.
contagion and miasma;
practical concerns >> theoretical
Scottish Enlightenment
Wm Cullen, theory/framework of nervous
irritability
Nosology
de Sauvagbes, and Cullen
fevers: typologies.
Cullen: foremost teacher of his age
John Brown, Brunonian medicine
Pathology
Origins of new aproach tht would be transformative:
-
Morgagni, 1761, De Sedibus
-
Baillies 1793.
-
Bichat 1799
-
localism: organs -->
-
tissues.
-
the doctrine of tissues.
-
disease: local.
Therapeutics
-
blood letting, and mercury; not much change.
Good air, travel, spas, waters growing popular.
-
Increasingly medication centered
-
but few drugs did much good; some dropped,
some new good ones added, like castor oil, zinc oxide, paregoric
-
Willow bark, 1763 ff
-
Digitalis, 1783 ff
-
Hahnemann: homeopathy
Insanity
-
new science, metaphysics, and neuroanatomy:
new ideas.
-
moral management
-
institutions for treatment.
-
disciplined order and resocialization.
Childbirth
Male midwife grad replace female midwifery,
save in Germany, Italy, Spain.
Upper class women > and > birth at home
with male physician.
By 1730, all have obstet forceps.
Prevention of Smallpox
Wortley Montagu, inoculation; [Mather-Boston
trial]; Maitland trial 1721. Popular. Dangers.
Jenner, 1798.
Surgery
-
some improvements, but still no major internal
operations;
-
lithotomy : lateral cystotomy: 1 minute!!
-
cataract
-
anal fistula
-
more and more formal education
-
screw tourniquet Petit
-
1794 French ed reform
-
infirmary as major site of trauma, emergency
treatment
-
John Hunter: superb expt, anatomy
Medicine and the People
Religion, magic, signatures, home remedies,
home health manuals, “Kitchen physick” Patent medicines, Quacks,
entrepreneurs, Joanna Stephens;
more and more regulation: career
of Mesmer and animal magnetism
Medicine, State and Society:
the Profession and its Institutions
-
elite - acad - state powers; lower - apprenticeship.
-
schools, licensing,
-
country to country variations.
-
German speaking very systematic, and hierarchical
in Prussia, Habsburg Empire.
-
England: free market, little regulation.
RCP a gentleman’s club in 18e.
-
Leiden and Edinburgh the star med schools.
-
Rise of private anatomy schools [England]
and hospitals as teaching institutions of great importance.
More and more public health: Frank’s
medical police
Lind and scurvy
1754 World’s first clinical trial.
specialist institutions:
lying in hospital
lunacy
cancer wards
dispensaries
humane societies
Disease and the Larger Picture
slavery and spread of disease
yellow fever
Industrial revolution
Malthus
“Enlightenment medicine made few positive
advances, but it became the basis of a new materially based science of
man, an anthropology in the widest sense, and a far from optimistic one.”
302
|