Notes on the Enlightenment

Porter, 245-303  Brief sketch;  “Enlightenment”


In Search of Medical Science
Lots of rival camps.  No unity.
Boerhaave:  bedside teaching, Leiden, chem
Hales: iatromechanics, expts.
Stahl: animism
Hoffman: mechanism
de Sauvages: midground
John Hunter: vitalist
La Mettrie: extreme materialist


more anatomy, Sommerring; Wolff,
Naturphilosophie

  • regeneration  - Trembley, Spallanzani

  • von Haller and irritability, vitalism.
  • Whytt

  • epigenesis vs. prefomation
     
     
    Three Warring Schools
    dualistic 
    mechanism
    animisim
    atheistic 
    reductionism
    Blumenbach
    John Hunter
    Galvani
    Volta
    Erasmus Darwin
    JB Lamarck
    • pneumatic chemistry and respiration
      • Cavendish, Black, Priestley, Lavoisier
      • Beddoes Institute

    Medicine in Practice

    • men of letters, philanthropists, improvers
      • E. Darwin, JC Lettsom
        • Bedside care
      • W. Heberden
    • 1761 Auenbruegger and percussion  Inventum novum
      • History still more important than 5 senses.

    The Study of Disease

    Fothergill, Lind, Dobson;
    Cheyne; Tissot
    Piecemeall advances, with fundamentals remaining contentious.
     contagion  and miasma;   practical concerns >> theoretical


    Scottish Enlightenment

    Wm Cullen, theory/framework of nervous irritability
    Nosology
    de Sauvagbes, and Cullen
    fevers: typologies.
    Cullen: foremost teacher of his age
    John Brown, Brunonian medicine


    Pathology

    Origins of new aproach tht would be transformative:

    • Morgagni, 1761, De Sedibus
      • localism [organs]
    • Baillies 1793.
    • Bichat 1799
      • localism: organs -->
        • tissues.
        • the doctrine of tissues.
    •   disease: local.



    Therapeutics
     

    • blood letting, and mercury; not much change.  Good air, travel, spas, waters growing popular.
    • Increasingly medication centered
      • but few drugs did much good; some dropped, some new good ones added, like castor oil, zinc oxide, paregoric
      • Willow bark, 1763 ff
      • Digitalis, 1783 ff
    • Hahnemann: homeopathy

    Insanity

    • new science, metaphysics, and neuroanatomy: new ideas.
    • moral management
      • institutions for treatment.
      • disciplined order and resocialization.


    Childbirth

    Male midwife grad replace female midwifery, save in Germany, Italy, Spain.
    Upper class women > and > birth at home with male physician.
    By 1730, all have obstet forceps.


    Prevention of Smallpox
    Wortley Montagu, inoculation; [Mather-Boston trial]; Maitland trial 1721.  Popular.  Dangers.
    Jenner, 1798.


    Surgery

    • some improvements, but still no major internal operations;
      • lithotomy : lateral cystotomy: 1 minute!!
      • cataract
      • anal fistula
    • more and more formal education
    • screw tourniquet Petit
    • 1794 French ed reform
    • infirmary as major site of trauma, emergency treatment
    • John Hunter: superb expt, anatomy

    Medicine and the People

    Religion, magic, signatures, home remedies, home health manuals, “Kitchen physick”  Patent medicines, Quacks, entrepreneurs, Joanna Stephens;
    more and more regulation:  career of Mesmer and animal magnetism


    Medicine, State and Society: the Profession and its Institutions
     

    • elite - acad - state powers; lower - apprenticeship.
      • schools, licensing,
      • country to country variations.
        • German speaking very systematic, and hierarchical in Prussia, Habsburg Empire.
        • England: free market, little regulation.  RCP a gentleman’s club in 18e.
        • Leiden and Edinburgh the star med schools.
      • Rise of private anatomy schools [England] and hospitals as teaching institutions of great importance.


    More and more public health: Frank’s medical police
    Lind and scurvy
    1754 World’s first clinical trial.

    specialist institutions:

  •  lying in hospital
  •  lunacy
  •  cancer wards
  •  dispensaries
  •  humane societies

  •  

     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     


    Disease and the Larger Picture

     slavery and spread of disease
     yellow fever
     Industrial revolution
     Malthus

    “Enlightenment medicine made few positive advances, but it became the basis of a new materially based science of man, an anthropology in the widest sense, and a far from optimistic one.” 302